The Boys Varsity Baseball team competes in the New York City Athletic League (NYCAL) and looks to qualify for the New York State Association of Independent Schools Tournament (NYSAIS). The team also travels to Florida for a pre-season Spring Training trip each year. The Knights have won the NYCAL league title and qualified for the NYSAIS Tournament in each of the last two years going undefeated (12-0) through the regular season and NYCAL playoffs in 2019.